Overview

Located in the heart of Muskego, Wisconsin, Irish Cottage II offers an inviting bar and grill experience that combines hearty fare with a warm, community-centered atmosphere. Nestled at s98w12532 Loomis Ct, this spot draws both locals and travelers seeking comfort food served with genuine hospitality.

The menu shines with a mix of classic and creative dishes. Standouts like the Ruben Rolls reimagine a beloved deli sandwich, wrapping the savory corned beef and tangy sauerkraut in a crispy egg roll shell, perfectly paired with a side of 1000 Island dressing. Steak lovers find satisfaction in the Ribeye Steak Sandwich, a generous, expertly cooked main that pairs well with the robust flavors of the Irish Coffee or a splash of Jack Daniel's Apple & Cranberry from the drink offerings.

Seafood options such as the Shrimp Plate and the crisp, crunchy fish featured in their popular Fish Fry provide variety and highlight the kitchen’s ability to cater to different tastes. The recently praised Jerk Chicken Wrap brings an unexpected twist with its bold, spicy seasoning, adding to the diverse, flavorful lineup. Appetizers like Garlic Cheese Curds and Pretzel Bites welcome you in with familiar, comforting options to share.

The setting at Irish Cottage II encourages a multifaceted experience. With indoor and outdoor seating, including an outdoor bar setup perfect for sunny days, it’s an ideal place to enjoy live music, casual dining, or even community events such as local car shows. This lively yet relaxed space caters to a broad audience — from families and groups of friends to sports fans looking for a friendly bar environment.

What sets Irish Cottage II apart is the attentive and personable staff, who enhance every visit with genuine care and prompt service. Regulars describe the staff as more like family than just employees, fostering a welcoming environment that invites repeat visits. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick burger on a road trip, indulging in large portions of taco specials, or savoring a perfectly cooked triple-decker sandwich, there’s a consistent sense of warmth and satisfaction throughout the dining experience.

In essence, Irish Cottage II blends robust bar and grill classics with subtle creative touches, all served in a vibrant, neighborhood hub. It’s a place where the food hits the spot, the drinks complement the meal, and the atmosphere makes you want to linger.


Amenities & Services

Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves alcohol
Serves beer
Serves cocktails
Serves coffee
Serves comfort food
Serves food at bar
Serves happy-hour drinks
Serves happy-hour food
Serves late-night food
Quick bite
Serves spirits
Serves wine
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy

What Customers Say

Scott Steinpas
Dec 10,2025
5/5
Fun time on a beautiful day outdoors. Live music from a great band with an outdoor bar set-up, grilled food, tent, car show, and great people. The staff was friendly and attentive both inside and out. Hats off to all!
Trucking With kingfish (Trucking with kingfish)
Dec 10,2025
5/5
On our way back to Milwaukee from lake Geneva we decided to take a break and since we were in the middle of no where we stopped. At the only place around so that’s how we found ourselves at the Irish cottage 2, the staff was friendly and the food arrived retry fast, I ordered a hamburger and it hit the spot perfectly, I wouldn’t hesitate to order a hamburger the next time we visit, Stacy ordered the fish plate and the fish was crisp and crunchy and wonderful so I stole one of her fish pieces, yes we will go back again and maybe we can go on a Friday for their fish fry
Sue
Dec 10,2025
5/5
Had steak sandwiches they were so good Will definitely come back
Justine Filapek
Dec 10,2025
5/5
Very nice pub & grill. Our server was very friendly and patient, answering our questions and bringing us our requests. My other group members had the taco special. They are HUGE. Definitely worth the price. They all enjoyed very much. I opted for the Reuben Rolls and the IC2 Burger. Good size burger and cooked perfectly to order, though the fries were overly salted. The Reuben Rolls are absolutely delicious. Think egg rolls with the filling as the contents of a Reuben sandwich, but with the 1000 Island as the dipping sauce on the side. YUM! Unfortunately, I dove in without taking my picture first so this is what I ended up taking home. I was also spying on the next table and was immersed in the aroma and appearance of the pizza they had. So I ordered one to go. Super thin crust the way I like. Tasty toppings. Of course I had to try one piece freshly cooked. Having some for lunch today and the rest for lunch tomorrow. Fun, vibrant atmosphere. Friendly staff and customers. Great neighborhood place for a bite to eat, hang at the bar, watch the game. Enjoy.
Chad Leipolt
Dec 10,2025
5/5
Our favorite place to eat. Delicious food, extremely friendly bartenders, feels more like family then just another customer. 5 stars
Jason Rice
Dec 10,2025
5/5
Wednesday nights is Mexican night and oh my gosh. Food is outstanding. Been there other nights and the food is great. Great people and great drinks. Wednesday you will find us there.
Valerie Tverberg
Dec 10,2025
4/5
Went Friday 9/22/23 for lunch We had the garlic cheese curds (too garlicky) beer battered cod fish fry (fish was pretty bland & a bit soggy) ribeye steak sandwich (huge & delicious) & the blue gill fish dinner (again bland & didn’t love the coating) The server/bartender was great!! Catered to the two little ones we had with us! They have slots, pull tabs & claw game. My take away is it would be better to go at night have a few beers, an app & play some slots/tabs
Jason
Dec 10,2025
4/5
A neat place with a wide variety of choices. We really enjoyed the Ribeye steak sandwich and the Reuben Rolls. The steak sandwich had a ton of mushrooms and fried onions. The bun was very crispy and delicious. The Reuben rolls were gigantic and very crispy. The staff was friendly, and it looks like a popular local watering hole. We decided to try it because we saw another review that mentioned it. It definitely was worth the drive. We will absolutely give it another go on the near future.

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Monday 11:00 AM - 02:00 AM
Tuesday 11:00 AM - 02:00 AM
Wednesday 11:00 AM - 02:00 AM
Thursday 11:00 AM - 02:00 AM
Friday 11:00 AM - 02:30 AM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 02:30 AM
Sunday 11:00 AM - 02:00 AM
Top Picks for You

More Bar & Grills in Muskego, Wisconsin, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!